Angela's Tools · Chapter 27 · Biodiversity Lab 1 of 3 · Recording sheet

Count the Kinds: Measuring Schoolyard Biodiversity with Quadrats

Investigation question: Does a regularly mowed lawn or a less-managed patch of the schoolyard hold more plant biodiversity, and how many quadrats does it take to find out?

Classroom field investigationGroups of 42 sessions Setup 10 · Activity 80 · Cleanup 10 min MS-LS2-4 · practiceMS-LS2-5 · supports
NameGroupDate

Your role today

Safety

Procedure

  1. Session 1, in class (5 minutes): write your prediction in q1 and answer q2. Look at the starter kind key and agree how your group will tell kinds apart (leaf shape, edges, hairs, how the leaves attach, flowers).
  2. At the first patch, the Site setter rolls one die for the position along the baseline (the roll times 50 cm) and the second die for the distance into the patch (the roll times 50 cm, measured with the meter stick), then lays the frame with its corner on that spot. If the frame lands on a path, a flagged hazard or an earlier quadrat, roll again; never move the frame to a spot that looks more interesting.
  3. Kind keeper and Recorder list every plant kind rooted inside the frame (the presence list). Each new kind gets the next class code, a sketch and a description in the kind key. Use the hand lens and do not pick the plant.
  4. Point reader lowers the pointer, blunt end down, straight through each of the 25 string intersections and calls the code of the first plant it touches; if it reaches soil, mulch or dead leaves without touching a living plant, call 'bare'. Recorder tallies every call. A partner watches that the pointer stays vertical.
  5. Repeat steps 2 to 4 for quadrats 2 and 3 in the same patch, then sample three quadrats in the second patch. Note the time, the weather and whether the lawn looks freshly mowed.
  6. Session 2: total each patch's hits by kind and leave 'bare' out of the plant total. For each kind compute p = hits ÷ plant total, square it, add the squares, and compute Simpson's index D = 1 − (sum of p²).
  7. Count each patch's richness: all kinds on your presence lists, whether or not the pointer hit them. Fill the accumulation table by counting how many kinds each quadrat added that earlier quadrats of the same patch had not.
  8. Copy your group's totals to the class chart. Using the class data in the order groups sampled, plot total kinds found against number of quadrats sampled for each patch on one graph, one color per patch. Compute the class Simpson's index for each patch from the pooled hits.
  9. Answer q3 and q4 on the recording sheet as a group, then the analysis questions individually.

Record your observations

Lab 1 recording sheet: Count the Kinds

You will sample three quadrats in Patch A (mowed lawn) and three in Patch B (less-managed patch). In each quadrat, list every plant kind you see (the presence list), then record the first plant touched at each of the 25 grid points. A point that touches only soil, mulch or dead leaves is bare. Use the class codes (K1, K2, ...) so every group means the same plant by the same code.

1.Prediction: which patch will have more plant kinds, and which will have a more even mix? Explain your reasoning using what mowing does to plants.
2.Why does the Site setter place quadrats by dice roll instead of choosing spots that look interesting? What would go wrong otherwise?
Kind key (add each new kind the first time you see it)
CodeDescription (leaf shape, edges, hairs, flowers)Quick sketchIn Patch A?In Patch B?
K1
K2
K3
K4
K5
K6
K7
K8
K9
K10
Point-intercept hits (tally the first plant touched at each of the 25 points)
KindA: Q1A: Q2A: Q3A totalB: Q1B: Q2B: Q3B total
K1
K2
K3
K4
K5
K6
K7
K8
K9
K10
Bare (soil, mulch, dead leaves)
Check: all points2525257525252575
Presence lists and accumulation
Patch and quadratCodes of kinds presentNumber presentNew kinds (not in earlier quadrats of this patch)Total kinds found so far in this patch
A, quadrat 1
A, quadrat 2
A, quadrat 3
B, quadrat 1
B, quadrat 2
B, quadrat 3
Simpson's index: p = hits ÷ plant total (leave out bare); D = 1 − sum of p²
KindPatch A hitsA: pA: p²Patch B hitsB: pB: p²
K1
K2
K3
K4
K5
K6
K7
K8
K9
K10
Plant total (no bare)1.001.00
Sum of p²
Simpson's index D
Kinds found as more quadrats are sampled (class data) Kinds found as more quadrats are sampled (class data) 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 Number of quadrats sampled Total plant kinds found
3.Report richness and Simpson's index for each patch, from your group's data and from the class data. Which patch has higher biodiversity by each measure?
4.Look at the accumulation curves. Did each curve level off? What does that tell you about whether the class found most of the kinds in each patch?

Analysis questions

5.Another class surveyed two patches with the same four plant kinds. Patch X had 40, 20, 10 and 10 plant hits; Patch Y had 74, 2, 2 and 2. Compute Simpson's index for each patch, showing your work, and explain which has higher biodiversity even though both have a richness of 4.
6.Compare your two patches using both richness and Simpson's index from the class data. Is the difference between the patches bigger than the differences among quadrats within one patch? Use numbers.
7.Your group's three quadrats and the class's 18 or more quadrats probably gave different richness for the same patch. Explain why, and say which value you trust more.
8.Write an argument: does mowing change which plants grow and how evenly they are mixed? State a claim, cite at least two numbers, explain the cause (what mowing does to tall plants compared with low-growing ones), and name one other difference between the patches that could also explain your result.
9.A classmate says the patch with the higher Simpson's index is 'healthier'. What else would you need to know before agreeing? Think about native and invasive plants.
10.The school plans to turn half of the lawn into a native pollinator garden. Design a before-and-after survey to judge whether the change increases biodiversity: what you would measure, how many quadrats, when, and one measurable criterion for success.
11.Name two limitations of the point-intercept method for measuring plant biodiversity, and say how each could bias your result.
Angela's Tools · Chapter 27 · BiodiversityLab 1 of 3 · Student recording sheet